Institutional Review of Seismological Research at New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology: 1957 through 1999








A. R. Sanford, R. C. Aster, J. W. Schlue, H. J. Tobin, and K. W. Lin



Geophysics Open-File Report 93
Earth and Environmental Science and
Geophysical Research Center
New Mexico Tech
Socorro, NM 87801





October, 2000


Abstract

A program of seismological research was initiated at New Mexico Tech in the late 1950’s. Our review presents a chronological history from 1957 through 1999 that documents the milestones and accomplishments of the program. Two major long-term and on-going projects during the over 40 years of research were (1) the physical characteristics of a highly unusual mid-crustal magma body in the central Rio Grande rift beneath Socorro, New Mexico and (2) the seismicity of New Mexico. Our review includes a section on the Socorro Magma Body that presents observations which best constrain its depth, extent, internal structure, relation to seismicity and other geophysical properties. A section on the regional seismicity studies (1) describes development of catalogs based on instrumental data (1962-1998) and pre-instrumental data (1869-1961), (2) presents and discusses the geographic distribution of earthquakes in New Mexico and (3) presents and discusses a seismic hazard map for the region.


We summarize the seismological research program at New Mexico Tech in three sections. The first is a chronological review of milestones and accomplishments from initiation of research in 1957 through 1999. The other two sections are devoted to updated summaries on two major long-term and ongoing research projects at New Mexico Tech; the Socorro Magma Body and Seismicity of New Mexico. Presented in the section on the Socorro Magma Body are the observations which best constrain the physical characteristics of this unusual mid-crustal structure in the central Rio Grande rift. The section on seismicity research describes recently completed earthquake catalogs for the period 1869 through 1998. Also presented and discussed in this section are maps of the distribution of earthquakes and seismic hazard for New Mexico.

Milestones and Accomplishments of the Seismological Research Program at New Mexico Tech: 1957 - 1999

1957 Allan R. Sanford (PhD California Institute of Technology) begins a 42 year research-teaching career at New Mexico Tech. Although Sanford’s dissertation was not in seismology, he gained experience in that field as a research assistant for C.F. Richter at the Caltech Seismological Laboratory.

1958 A review of published data on earthquakes, primarily U.S. Earthquakes and some abstracts by S.A. Northrop at the University of New Mexico, suggests an unusually high level on earthquake activity in the central Rio Grande rift, particularly at Socorro.

1959 (1) In the fall of this year, Merle Tuve of the Carnegie Institute, Washington D.C. loans New Mexico Tech a high-magnification continuous-recording seismograph. During a 3-day trial, 49 very small earthquakes are recorded, 40 within 20 km of Socorro.

(2) Charles R. Holmes (PhD Pennsylvania State University) joins the research-teaching staff at New Mexico Tech. Holmes’ expertise in instrumentation is of great value in the early years of the seismology research program.

1960 (1) A high-magnification (up to 10 million at 20 Hz), high-resolution (15 mm/sec, 30 mm/sec and 60 mm/sec), three channel seismograph begins intermittent operation in June at station SNM (in mountains 5 km west of Socorro) and records many small shocks, including some from a major earthquake swarm ~40 km north of Socorro in July.

(2) In late summer a Carnegie Institution vertical-component high-magnification (9 million at 20 Hz) seismograph begins around-the-clock monitoring at station SNM; recording that has continued uninterrupted to the present there or at nearby station WTX.

1961 First paper on seismological research at New Mexico Tech is published in the Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America (Sanford and Holmes, 1961). This paper presents an analysis of high-resolution seismograms of earthquakes from a July 1960 swarm located ~40 km north of Socorro. We believe this is the first paper on earthquakes in New Mexico based on instrumental data. We now know this strong 1960 swarm occurred near the northern boundary of the Socorro Seismic Anomaly (SSA), an ~5200 km2 cluster of earthquake activity that overlies the Socorro Magma Body (SMB). The BSSA paper calls attention to strong distinct arrivals other than direct P an S on the seismograms and suggests that one set of matched phases are PzP and SzS reflections from a crustal discontinuity. We now realize that these phases were the first recordings of reflections from the SMB.

1962 Publication in the JGR (Sanford and Holmes, 1962) of the results of a 20 month instrumental study of Socorro area microearthquakes with magnitudes as low as ?1.0 (ultra-microearthquakes). The study is patterned after one conducted earlier in Japan (Asada, 1957) and is believed to be the first of its kind in the U.S. A major result of the study is that microearthquakes with magnitudes ranging from 0.7 to ?1.0 follow a linear relation between the log cumulative number of events and magnitude with a slope value (~1.0) similar to that observed for larger earthquakes. Also like larger earthquakes, the paper demonstrates that very weak earthquakes near Socorro are not random mutually independent events.

1963 A published review of historical seismicity in the Socorro area prior to 1960 (Sanford, 1963), including quotes from Socorro newspapers for the prolonged and very strong 1906-07 earthquake swarm and the earlier 1904 swarm.

1965 (1) The first of a long series of publications on the seismicity of New Mexico based on instrumental data (Sanford, 1965). The two and one-half years of recording demonstrate the existence of relatively strong earthquakes in the Great Plains and Colorado Plateau, physiographic provinces thought to be tectonically stable. The outline of a small by active seismogenic province in the central Rio Grande rift near Socorro, the SSA, is apparent but not recognized as such because of the short recording period.

(2) Publication of the first paper (Sanford and Long, 1965) that presents and analyses data on strong SzP and SzS reflection phases observed on microearthquake seismograms in the Socorro area. A depth to the reflecting crustal discontinuity is estimated (18 km) based on high-resolution (15 mm/sec, 30 mm/sec and 60 mm/sec) recordings. An analysis of the amplitude ratios, SzP/S and SzS/S, indicates that they are much too large to be explained by a planar discontinuity across which the velocity increases by up to 33%. This is the first evidence suggesting that the crustal reflector has unusual properties.

1968 New Mexico Tech receives a surplus LRSM (VELA Program) recording van with short-period and long-period vertical and horizontal seismometers. Continuous three-component short-period recording begins on magnetic tape and 35 mm film in mid-year.

1969 First remote station in Socorro area (SRM) put into operation by New Mexico Tech June 1 at a location ~30 km north of station SNM. This station has a unique recording system that produces successive 6 hour helical records on 70 mm film (at a trace speed of 1 mm/sec) for up to a three-week period without servicing.

1970 January: Beginning of collaboration with the USGS Albuquerque Seismological Laboratory with the deployment of two of their long-term magnetic-tape recording seismographs in the Socorro area (stations SBB and SCC).

1970-1974 Four papers published on numerical simulations of the elastic dynamic characteristics of propagating fractures (Hanson and Sanford, 1970; Hanson and Sanford, 1971; Hanson et al., 1971; and Hanson et al., 1974). These papers present time histories of displacements near a fracture that appears suddenly, accelerates to a constant fracture velocity, decelerates and stops. Tensile and shear fractures are simulated with fewer constraints than earlier analytical solutions.

1972 (1) First of several published papers on the seismicity of the Rio Grande rift in New Mexico (Sanford et al., 1972). This New Mexico Bureau of Mines Circular contains a review of (1) felt reports of earthquakes 1869 to 1960, (2) instrumental studies from 1960 through 1970 with special emphasis on the Socorro area and (3) estimates of seismicity based on Quaternary faults in the Socorro area.

(2) A collaborative study of earthquakes in northeastern New Mexico and the Texas Panhandle with Stuart A. Northrop (University of New Mexico), the leading pioneer in the investigation of earthquakes in New Mexico and bordering areas (Northrop and Sanford, 1972). This may be the best summary of activity in the NE New Mexico-Texas Panhandle region from 1907 through 1971, and it documents the existence of strong earthquakes along the eastern terminus of an ENE band of seismicity extending from central New Mexico near Socorro. This seismicity straddles a prominent topographic lineation extending from SW Arizona, and geologic and geophysical features along its trace suggest the existence of a major Precambrian crustal flaw which we have named the Socorro Fracture Zone (Sanford and Lin, 1998).

1973 Publication of a second paper (Sanford et al., 1973) on observations and interpretation of sharp impulsive SzP and SzS reflection phases from a mid-crustal discontinuity observed on Socorro area microearthquake seismograms. Presented are arguments supporting the reflection phases interpretation and an estimate of depth (17.8 km) to the reflecting discontinuity and its dip (6º to the north). In later studies, the depth increases slightly and the dip disappears because of a better crustal velocity model. Perhaps the most important result of the paper is based on observed SzP/SzS amplitude ratios for five different offset distances. These ratios are compared with theoretical values for two reflecting discontinuities; one across which the S velocity increases, the other across which it drops to zero. The latter discontinuity produces theoretical values much closer to the observations and is the first evidence suggesting that the SzP, SzS reflector could be underlain by material of very low rigidity.

1974 (1) A report on the seismicity of the proposed Waste Isolation Pilot Project (WIPP) in southeastern New Mexico is presented in a circular of the New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources (Sanford and Toppozada, 1974). This is the first report arising from an association with this project from 1972 to the present. In March 1999, the first shipments of nuclear waste were received at this permanent long-term storage facility, a milestone in the solution to the nuclear waste problem in this country. The Sanford and Toppozada report summarizes data on earthquakes and Quaternary faulting within 300 km of the WIPP site. A deterministic estimate of hazard at the WIPP site utilizing the historical seismicity and fault scarp information is presented. The question of induced seismicity from oil field operations in SE New Mexico and West Texas is discussed.

(2) New Mexico Tech deploys the first continuously recording seismograph at WIPP.

1975 Beginning of a multi-year study of Socorro microearthquakes employing a movable array of 5 to 6 Sprengnether MEQ 800 seismographs supplemented in 1977 with two Sprengnether DR 100 digital recording systems.

1976 (1) Publication of a report on the seismicity of the Los Alamos National Laboratory based on the historical data (felt and instrumental) from 1873 through May, 1972 (Sanford, 1976). Results of this study have been superceded by several detailed investigations by LANL seismologists and geologists.

(2) John Schlue (PhD University of California at Los Angeles) assumes a research-teaching position at New Mexico Tech. Schlue brings to the geophysics program expertise in long-period seismology and inverse methods, the latter of particular value to many MS and PhD students working with the Socorro microearthquake data.

(3) Seismic data from the nuclear explosion Gasbuggy are used to determine the crustal structure of the Rio Grande rift, particularly from Albuquerque southward (Toppozada and Sanford, 1976). A depth of 18.6 km for the Conrad discontinuity suggests a connection with the depth of the low rigidity layer postulated from amplitudes of crustal reflections on microearthquakes (Sanford et al., 1973).

1977 Progress report in AGU Geophysical Monograph 20 (Sanford et al., 1977) on research with SzP and SzS reflections on Socorro microearthquakes completed through mid-1976. Cumulative observations support contention that reflections are from the upper surface of a mid-crustal magma body (SMB). First map on the geographic extent of the magma body is presented.

1977-1978 First published observations believed to support the existence of small magma bodies above the mid-crustal magma body (Chapin et al., 1978 and Sanford, 1977). Preliminary maps of their locations.

1979 (1) A collaborative publication on the seismicity of the Rio Grande rift with Los Alamos National Laboratory and the U.S.G.S. Albuquerque Seismological Laboratory (Sanford, Olsen and Jaksha, 1979). A review of seismicity along the rift from 1849-1977 with special emphasis on microearthquake studies centered on Los Alamos, Albuquerque and Socorro.

(2) Revised estimates of characteristics of the Socorro midcrustal magma body (Rinehart et al., 1979). Evidence is presented for a thin (<1.2 km) essentially flat sill-like magma body at a depth of 19 to 20 km with a minimum lateral extent of 1700 km2. Inverse methods are used to establish depth to and S-wave velocity above the magma body. Impounding of basalt magma at a strong Conrad discontinuity is presented as an explanation for the location of the magma body. The flatness of the upper surface of the magma body beneath structures with fault offsets of up to 3.8 km is cited as possible evidence for detachment of a brittle uppermost crust from a plastic zone at lower levels of the upper crust.

1979-1980 Publication of results of deep crustal reflection profiling of the Rio Grande rift near Socorro (Brown et al., 1979; Brown et al., 1980), a project conducted by the COCORP group at Cornell University with some assistance from New Mexico Tech (Chapin and Sanford). Among the many important features of the rift’s shallow and deep structure revealed by the study is a very strong complex reflector corresponding in depth to the upper surface of the magma body inferred from SzP to SzS reflection phases on microearthquake seismograms. Spectral studies of the P-wave reflected waveforms are consistent with but not unique to a thin layer of magma.

1980 (1) A published analysis of releveling data in the Socorro area by a Cornell University group with some assistance from Sanford (Reilinger et al., 1980). Observations support a spatial relation between the geographic location of the midcrustal magma body and rates of vertical crustal movement in the range of millimeters a year.

(2) A published analysis of trilateration surveys of a geodetic network across the Rio Grande rift near Socorro by a U.S.G.S. group with some assistance from Sanford (Savage et al., 1980). Surveys of the geodetic network in 1972, 1973, 1976 and 1979 reveal no measurable extension during 1972-1979 and place an upper bound (2 s.d.) limit of 1 mm/yr on the spreading rate across the 50 km breath of the Rio Grande rift. A subsequent paper by Savage et al. (1985) incorporates results of a later resurvey and places additional constraints of the spreading rate.

1981 Two papers utilizing inverse methods to analyze data obtained from 1975-1977 by a movable array of seismographs in the Socorro area are published. Rinehart and Sanford (1981) use SzS travel time data to obtain average values for depth and S-wave velocity to the mid-crustal magma body. Ward et al. (1981) uses direct P-wave arrival times to obtain a three dimensional map of crustal velocities from the surface to ~10 km. No statistically significant velocity differences are found within the upper 4 km but a block of crust with an unusually low velocity is defined below 4 km southwest of Socorro where other observations suggest the existence of shallow magma bodies.

1982 (1) John Knapp (PhD University of Washington) joins the research-teaching staff at New Mexico Tech and adds expertise in exploration seismology, seismotectonics and inverse methods to the seismology program.

(2) A review paper on magma chambers in rifts with Pall Einarsson, a seismologist from Iceland (Sanford and Einarsson, 1982). Massive amounts of magma have been intruded and extruded along continental rifts over geologic time. However, the small number of active volcanoes along continental rifts at this time suggests that movement of detectable amounts of magma from the asthenosphere into the crust is a relatively rare event on a human time scale. When injection of magma does occur, it should produce a number of geophysical anomalies that make detection possible and reasonably certain. The Rio Grande rift near Socorro appears to be one of a few areas within continental rifts worldwide where a suite of geophysical observations indicates the existence of a thin magma chamber in the crust. Although composition of the magma cannot be determined, geologic as well as geophysical considerations suggest impoundment of basaltic magma immediately below the Conrad discontinuity.

(3) Lawrence Jaksha becomes a U.S.G.S. seismologist in residence at New Mexico Tech. He brings to the seismology research program extensive experience with networks. It is doubtful that the program of monitoring local and regional seismicity at New Mexico Tech could have grown without his expertise in telemetry and all other aspects of seismic instrumentation.

(4) Installation of eight permanent telemetered seismograph stations in the Socorro area, a network which continues in operation to the present time.

1983 A re-examination of the results of six MS student studies on the detection of magma bodies in the upper crust indicates a serious flaw in their design (Sanford, 1983). A major conclusion of the new analysis is that all mapped locations of upper crustal magma bodies in the six studies are suspect. Anomalously high Poisson’s ratios, abnormally low dominant S-wave frequency and unusually high amplitude ratios for direct P to direct S can best be explained by small pockets of magma very close to the microearthquake hypocenters.

1984 New Mexico Tech is one of 26 universities to join in the establishment of IRIS.

1985-1987 Two papers on apparent Q of upper crustal rocks in the Socorro area are published (Carpenter and Sanford, 1985; and Carpenter et al., 1987). High quality digital recordings of Socorro microearthquakes in the magnitude range of ?0.9 to 0.3 are used in the studies. Values of Qs for the low velocity surface layer are determined for eight sites; all are less than 50. The average upper crust Qs value (exclusive of the low velocity layer) is 535 (95% confidence interval 374-938). Observed Qp/Qs ratios are highly variable, 0.34-1.39, and postulated to be the result of differences in the water content of crustal rocks. Qp and Qs are found to be independent of frequency at the 95% confidence level in 16 of 18 cases examined.

1986 Results of primarily an instrumental study of the seismicity of the Rio Grande rift from Socorro to Santa Fe by Jaksha (with some assistance from Sanford) published in JGR (Jaksha and Sanford, 1986). The 66 month study from 1976-1981 reveals that most of the activity within the rift is from Belen to Socorro and that the clustering of earthquakes in that region is not an artifact of instrumental location. Several off rift areas account for much of the activity during the 5 1/2 year study.

1988 A paper presenting new evidence for the existence and internal structure of the SMB is published (Ake and Sanford, 1988). Spectra of PzP and SzS phases from digital seismograms are used to model the internal structure of the mid-crustal magma body. Because events used for the study are very small (magnitudes less than zero), a delta-like source pulse could be assumed. Further discussion of the results of this study appear in the section on the Socorro Magma Body later in this review.

1991 (1) A second collaborative publication on the seismicity of the Rio Grande rift (RGR) with Los Alamos National Laboratory and the U.S.G.S. Albuquerque Seismological Laboratory in the book Neotectonics of North America (Sanford, Jaksha and Cash, 1991). In order to understand the seismicity of the RGR, distribution of earthquakes throughout the state from 1868 through 1986 is presented and discussed with special emphasis on instrumental studies centered on Los Alamos, Albuquerque and Socorro.

(2) Richard Aster is hired during the Fall semester as Assistant Professor of Geophysics. Two grants were awarded to Aster funding research on Faulting and Stress in the Anza Seismic Gap (Los Alamos) and Analysis of Similar Earthquakes in Seismic Gaps (USGS). Notable Aster publications include reply to Crampin et al. comments on shear wave anisotropy measurements and interpretation (Aster et al., 1991), Borehole seismic anisotropy measurements in southern California showing strong shallow anisotropic signature and strong attenuation (Aster et al., 1991b,c).

1992 Publication of a procedure for incorporating Socorro Magma Body reflections into the earthquake location process (Hartse et al., 1992). Development of the procedure produces an improved one dimensional velocity model and a better constrained magma body depth. Application of the procedure decreases uncertainties in focal depths by up to a factor of three. Aster publications include a study of stress-induced versus mineral alignment anisotropy in southern California (Aster and Shearer, 1992) and a comprehensive summary of caldera resurgence and seismicity in the Campi Flegrei, Italy (Aster et al., 1992). Aster also initiated collaboration with Sandia National Laboratories through the SURP program in verification related research on seismic signal-to-noise in boreholes.

1993 Aster publications include work on comprehensive identification and classification of similar earthquakes in large microearthquake data sets (Aster and Scott, 1993). Aster initiates a cooperative research project to perform teleseismic recording above the Socorro magma body in association with John Schlue and Robert Meyer [U. of Wisconsin]. This field project will last until mid-1994.

1994 Aster publications include a comprehensive study of stress and faulting in the vicinity of a prominent San Andreas fault system seismic gap (Hartse et al., 1994).

1995 Aster publications include a study using repeating or near-repeating earthquakes to constrain velocity variations in the vicinity of seismic gaps (Haase et al., 1995). New NSF funding obtained for volcanic research on Mount Erebus, in association with Phil Kyle [NMT]. New funding obtained for analysis of seismicity related to geothermal energy development, in association with Mike Fehler [LANL]. New association established with Sandia National Labs on matched filtering event detection and location; this project will grow into Mitch Withers' Ph.D. research.

1996 Aster publications include two key papers on using repeating and near-repeating earthquakes to constrain temporal variability in seismic coda measurements (Aster et al., 1996; Antolik et al., 1996). Schlue, Aster, and Meyer (1996) publish a teleseismic study on the Socorro magma body that finds mid-crustal conversions hinting at a lower-crustal extension (a possible magma conduit) in its northwestern quadrant. Aster and Kyle install first broadband seismometers on Mount Erebus. Aster is promoted to Associate Professor of Geophysics and given tenure. Aster begins term as an Associate Editor of the Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America.

1997 (1) A new map of the geographic extent of the Socorro Magma Body (Balch et al., 1997). The lateral extent of the SMB is increased to ~3400 km2 utilizing 5400 reflection points, more than an order of magnitude greater than any previous study.

(2) Aster begins association with the Princeton Earth Physics Project to install broadband seismometers in and provide new seismology teaching materials for New Mexico Schools.

(3) Harold Tobin (Ph.D. University of California, Santa Cruz) assumes a research and teaching position with the program. Tobin brings expertise in marine geophysics, fault zone imaging, and physical properties of rocks and sediments to the group. Tobin develops a rock physics laboratory for high-pressure seismic velocity measurement and other experiments, and conducts research in fault physics in collaboration with the Sandia National Lab geomechanics group and others.

1998 Rowe et al. (1998) publish paper on very-long-period harmonic signals at Mount Erebus associated with its conduit system and excited by Strombolian explosions. Withers et al. (1998) publish comprehensive review paper on automated global seismic phase and event detection in the context of global teleseismic monitoring. New Mexico Tech is awarded operation of the NSF IRIS PASSCAL Instrument Center (P.I.'s Aster, Tobin, Romero). NMT builds a custom-designed building and warehouse in the Tech Industrial Park to house the 12-FTE facility. A major new project is initiated to record and analyze teleseismic data from a long-line (1000 km) broadband study of the Rio Grande rift, Jemez lineament, and Colorado Plateau (RISTRA); P.I.'s are Aster, Schlue, Jim Ni [NMSU], Steve Grand [UT Austin], and Scott Baldridge [Los Alamos].

1999 The IRIS PASSCAL Instrument Center reaches its full initial staffing complement of 11 full-time employees, supporting world-wide seismological field research.

The Socorro Magma Body

Introduction

The chronology of the research on the Socorro Magma Body is given in the first section of this institutional review. Presented below are the observations which are believed to best constrain the physical characteristics of this highly unusual geologic structure.

Evidence for Magma

The direct evidence for magma comes from analyses of amplitudes and spectra of reflected phases; PzP, SzP and SzS on microearthquake seismograms and PzP on COCORP crustal reflection profiles. Emphasized here are results of the New Mexico Tech studies of the microearthquake reflection phases. Data used in this research were from seismograms of small events, magnitudes generally less than zero, where reflected phases were not obscured by the codas of the direct P and S phases.

Amplitude versus Offset-AVO. From the very earliest observations of the microearthquake reflections (e.g. Sanford and Long, 1965), the amplitudes of these phases were found difficult to explain by single discontinuities across which the velocity increased. With the accumulation of more data it became possible to compare observed and theoretical ratios of SzP/SzS for offsets ranging from 5û to 30û (Sanford et al., 1973; Sanford et al., 1977; and Rinehart et al., 1979). The misfit for the case of the solid to solid Conrad discontinuity in the RGR (Toppozada and Sanford, 1976) was very large. Single discontinuities separating rigid and full or partial melts provided the best but not perfect match between observed and theoretical ratos.

Phase Changes and Waveform Characteristics. Digital microearthquake seismograms of a 1977 swarm 16 km southwest of Socorro were used to determine phase and waveform characteristics of PzP and SzS phases (Ake and Sanford, 1988). SzS and PzP undergo 180º phase reversals upon reflection, an indication that the first layer of any reflection producing structure is non-rigid. High correlation coefficients between S and SzS phases indicate little if any S wave energy penetrates beyond the first discontinuity, an indication that the underlying material lacks rigidity and is most likely magma from geologic considerations.

Internal Structure

The durations of PzP microearthquake reflections on digital seismograms range from 0.27 to 0.32 seconds which is nearly the same time range for mid-crustal reflections observed on COCORP profiles (Brocher, 1981). These durations place limits on the thickness of the magma body over much of its geographic extent. Ake and Sanford (1988) employed forward modeling of PzP phase to support the contention that the magma body is thin yet has resolvable differences in internal structure over distances as short as one-half kilometer. The preferred model for the SMB 16 km southwest of Socorro is a layer of full melt ~70 m thick underlain by layer of crystalline mush ~60 m thick.

Depth

The most reliable depth to the SMB, 18.75 ±0.28 (1 s.d.) km, was obtained from a simultaneous inversion for the one-dimensional velocity structure to and depth of the mid-crustal structure (Hartse et al., 1992). Earlier depth estimates from 17.8 km to 19.2 km were based on less constrained models of the average velocity structure to the SMB (Sanford and Long, 1965; Sanford et al., 1973; and Rinehart and Sanford, 1981).

Attitude

Examination of arrival time residuals for reflections PzP, SzP and SzS shows an even distribution of positive and negative residuals over the entire extent of the magma body for all reflected phases (Hartse et al., 1992; Balch et al., 1997). These observations indicate that the upper surface of the SMB is flat and horizontal.

Geographic Extent

A map of the geographic extent of the magma body was prepared using 697 PzP, 2169 SzP, and 2589 SzS reflections observed on seismograms recorded from 1975 to 1995 (Balch et al., 1997). The data indicate an area somewhat greater than 3400 km2. Increases in the reported lateral extent of the magma body from 1200 km2 (Sanford et al., 1977) to the present 3400 km2 are the result of larger data sets both in number and wider distribution of stations in the Socorro area.

Position in the Crust

The SMB has a depth, 18.75 km, which coincides closely with the position of the Conrad mid-crustal discontinuity, 18.6 km, determined from a seismic refraction profile through the central RGR (Toppozada and Sanford, 1976). Sanford has suggested that basaltic magma rises to the level of the Conrad discontinuity where it encounters two conditions which impede its upward migration (Sanford and Einarsson, 1982). First it encounters a lower density crustal rock which reduces the buoyancy of the rising magma. Second, the crustal models by Hartse et al. (1992) and Singer (1989) indicate a decrease in velocity below the base of the seismogenic zone at ~10 km. The lower velocity and absence of earthquakes suggests a plastic crustal layer between the Conrad and the seismogenic zone that acts as a seal to further upward migration of the basaltic magma.

Seismicity

The Socorro Seismic Anomaly (SSA) is a region of unusually high earthquake activity in the central Rio Grande rift. This seismogenic province occupies ~5000 km2, is centered over the SMB, and is surrounded by a clear aseismic halo. Sanford et al. (1995) have suggested that this distribution of seismicity can be explained by stresses arising from inflation of the SMB.

Uplift

Surface uplift determined from releveling of elevation benchmarks is centered on the SMB (Larsen et al., 1986). Maximum uplift near the center of the SMB averaged ~2.0 mm/year from 1911 through 1980 which is in good agreement with uplift rates over the past 20,000 years based on geomorphic evidence (Ouchi, 1983).

Teleseismic Structure

Sheetz and Schlue (1992) used receiver functions to look at the underside of the magma body; their modeling suggested both the top and bottom of the body present sharp velocity contrasts with surrounding material, with thickness between 25m ? 200m and shear wave speeds of 0.4 km/s ? 0.6 km/s.

In 1996, Schlue, Aster, and Meyer used arrivals from deep events from the Tonga-Fiji region, again to illuminate the underside of the SMB. This study noted evidence for a possible magma conduit near the western edge of the SMB that extends about 6 km into the lower crust.

Seismicity of New Mexico - 1869 through 1998: Distribution and Hazard

Introduction

The record of historical seismicity for New Mexico begins in the mid-nineteenth century. Although settlement by the Spanish began in 1598, little is known of earthquake activity in the state prior to its becoming a territory of the United States in 1848. No doubt, reports of earthquakes exist in Spanish and Mexican archives; such information, however, is difficult to extract, and to our knowledge no such attempt has been made. The earliest report after U. S. occupation is the description of a swarm of shocks in the Rio Grande valley at Socorro by an U. S. Army surgeon (Hammond, 1966). No shock in this 22 event swarm from 11 December 1849 through 8 February 1850 was felt at distances greater than 25 km, an indication that these earthquakes did not exceed magnitude 3.5. Similar sequences of shocks located away from population centers in the state could easily have gone unreported before the start of instrumental studies in 1962. For this reason, the interval before 1962 is restricted to felt earthquakes with intensities of ground motion indicating magnitudes of 4.5 or greater. The earliest reported earthquake equaling or exceeding this magnitude threshold occurred near or at Socorro in 1869.

Seismicity from Instrumental Recording: 1962 through 1998

In the period from 1962 through 1998, several organizations used instruments to locate and determine strengths of earthquakes in New Mexico and bordering areas; notably New Mexico Tech (NMT), Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL), U.S. Geological Survey (USGS), and the University of Texas at El Paso (UTEP). The periods of operation, number and sensitivity of instruments, and procedures for locating and assigning magnitudes were highly variable amongst these organizations during the 37-year period. For this reason, Sanford et al. (1995) and Sanford et al. (1997) undertook the project of collating data from all organizations into a comprehensive and consistent earthquake catalog for New Mexico and bordering areas. A major effort was made to have all magnitudes in the catalog based on or tied to a New Mexico duration magnitude scale (Newton et al., 1976; Ake et al., 1983). For determining magnitudes we used the relation

Md = 2.79 log Td - 3.63,

where Td is the duration in seconds. This relation was first developed by Dan Cash at LANL (Newton et al., 1976) for earthquakes in northern New Mexico. Later an essentially identical relation was derived at NMT (Ake et al., 1983) for earthquakes in central and southern New Mexico. The duration magnitude scales of both organizations are tied to the local magnitude scale which Hanks and Kanamori (1979) have demonstrated is equivalent to the moment magnitude.

The location program selected for the catalog was SEISMOS (Hartse, 1991). Originally developed to obtain hypocenters for earthquakes within or near a local network, it was modified to also locate regional earthquakes. SEISMOS like other inverse method location programs, e.g. HYPO71 (Lee and Lahr, 1975) and HYPOINVERSE (Klein, 1978), fails to obtain reasonable locations for regional events detected by small aperture networks. For the 37 years of New Mexico instrumental recording, this was a frequent occurrence. Lin (1994) and Lin and Sanford (1998) solved this problem by developing a fuzzy logic algorithm that obtains a highly reliable initial estimate of the epicenter for input into the SEISMOS program. Generation of the NMT catalog required relocation of nearly all of the earthquakes using SEISMOS modified to include the fuzzy-logic algorithm.

We have determined that the most accurate locations for regional earthquakes in New Mexico are obtained by using Pg and Sg arrivals only and a simple half-space crustal model with a velocity of 6.15 km/sec and a Poisson's ratio of 0.25. For earthquakes near Socorro, a more complex crustal structure is used in order to incorporate reflections into the location process.

The NMT catalog contains epicenters and magnitudes for over 2000 earthquakes with moment magnitudes greater or equal to 1.3; 89.1% from NMT, 6.8% from LANL, 3.5% from USGS, and 0.6% from UTEP. Tests indicate that a low cut-off magnitude of 2.0 assures completeness of the earthquake data throughout the study area since 1962. Therefore, presented here in Figure 1 are only those New Mexico earthquakes from 1962 through 1998 whose moment magnitudes are greater or equal to 2.0. Their distribution by magnitude is 581 greater or equal to magnitude 2.0, 117 greater or equal to magnitude 3.0, and 18 greater or equal to magnitude 4.0. A second map (Figure 2) shows the distribution of the earthquakes with moment magnitudes of 3.0 or greater.

 

Strongest Earthquakes in New Mexico-1869 through 1998

The historical record of earthquakes in New Mexico extends back to the middle of the 19th century. However, prior to 1962, the strengths of nearly all earthquakes were expressed in terms of the maximum intensity, Io, a quantity assigned on the basis of what people observe during an earthquake and damage to structures. The scale used for ranking earthquake intensity in United States is the Modified Mercalli-Revised 1931 (Richter, 1958). An empirical relation between maximum intensity and duration magnitude (equivalent to moment magnitude) has been derived by Sanford (1998) for New Mexico earthquakes:

Md = 0.5 + 2/3 Io.

This equation was used to convert maximum observed intensities for shocks prior to 1962 into magnitudes in order to obtain a list of strongest earthquakes with the same measure of strength.

The difficulty with using maximum intensity reports as a measure of the strength of an earthquake is that it implies the existence of people and/or structures directly at the epicenter of the shock. Therefore the reliability of the reports is dependent on population density which was very low for nearly all of New Mexico for the period prior to 1962. To reduce but not eliminate any population density problems, we have restricted our list of strongest earthquakes for the period prior to 1962 to shocks with maximum reported intensities of VI or greater. This places a lower limit of moment magnitude 4.5 on the list of strongest earthquakes. Data on the 30 earthquakes equaling or exceeding magnitude 4.5 from 1869 through 1998 are given in Table l and a map of their locations is presented in Figure 3

Geographic Distribution of New Mexico Earthquakes

The most striking feature of the seismicity in Figure 1 is the tight cluster of earthquake activity in the Rio Grande valley near Socorro. This Socorro Seismic Anomaly (SSA) occupies only 1.6% of the total area of the state but accounts for 37% of the earthquakes of magnitude 2.0 or greater in Figure 1 and 47% of the earthquakes of magnitude 4.5 or greater in Figure 3. The SSA is believed to be the result of crustal extension over an inflating mid-crustal magma body. The magma body is ~150 m thick, ~19 km deep, and has a lateral extent of 3400 km2 (Ake and Sanford, 1988; Hartse et al., 1992; Balch et al., 1997). Level-line data indicate that the surface above the magma body is undergoing uplift at a maximum rate of ~1.8 mm/year (Larsen et al., 1986) presumably because of injection of new magma into the thin extensive mid-crustal chamber.

In Figure 1 the pattern of seismicity outside the SSA is diffuse and well-defined seismic trends are not apparent. However, on the map of magnitude 3.0 or greater shocks (Figure 2), an interesting alignment of shocks does appear. Extending east-northeast from the SSA into the Great Plains of eastern New Mexico is a band of epicenters that straddles the trace of a prominent topographic lineation identified by Thelin and Pike (1991) on a digital shaded relief map they generated for the conterminous United States. The lineation, a possible fracture zone of Precambrian origin, extends 1400 km east-northeast from southwestern Arizona to the Texas Panhandle-Oklahoma border (Sanford and Lin, 1998). The ~85 km wide track of this feature is defined by a lineation of many features such as rivers, elongate depressions, faults, and probably the contemporaneous seismicity in Figures 1 and 2. Using Monte Carlo techniques, we have tested the possibility that the alignment of epicenters overlying the topographic lineation is accidental. The earthquakes of magnitude 3.0 or greater outside the SSA in Figure 2 were randomly distributed over the state nearly 1000 times without reproducing the major east-northeast band of seismicity; a band that occupies 9 % of the total area of the state but produces 22 % of the earthquakes outside the SSA.

A large fraction of the earthquakes in northern New Mexico appear to be related to the Jemez lineament (Aldrich and Laughlin, 1984), a fracture zone that extends from southwest of Grants to Los Alamos and Espanola in the Rio Grande valley and then on along an east-northeast track to beyond the northeast corner of the state (Figure 1). The Jemez lineament is a 50 km to 80 km wide leaky fracture zone defined by many hundreds of magmatic eruptive centers, including the very large aseismic Jemez volcanic complex just west of Los Alamos (Sanford et al., 1991).

Perhaps the most unusual characteristic of earthquake activity from 1962-1998 is its failure to define the Rio Grande rift (RGR), a major continental rift extending north-south through the state from north of Taos to south of Las Cruces (Chapin, 1971 and 1979). The overwhelming majority of Quaternary faults in New Mexico (Machette, 1998) are associated with the RGR and yet earthquakes are absent or nearly so over much of its extent; for example, from just south of Socorro to just north of Las Cruces.

Probabilistic Seismic Hazard in New Mexico

A probabilistic seismic hazard map (Reiter, 1990) based on the 37 years of instrumental data is presented in Figure 4. Hazard is given in terms of maximum horizontal ground acceleration (expressed as a fraction of gravitational acceleration-g) with a 10% probability of exceedance in 50 years, an appropriate time scale for most structures in New Mexico. The map indicates seismic hazard throughout New Mexico is moderate to low with maximum horizontal ground motion ranging from a high of 0.18g within the SSA to near zero for much of the state (Lin et al., 1997; Lin, 1999). A horizontal ground acceleration of 0.2g can do considerable damage, for example, chimneys broken at roof lines, but not major destruction.

Geologic mapping has revealed faults in New Mexico that have produced major earthquakes in the Quaternary, particularly along the RGR (Machette, 1998). However, the recurrence interval between these magnitude 7 or greater shocks is many thousands of years, and therefore, they have no effect on a 50-year, 10% probability of exceedance seismic hazard map (Lin and Sanford, 1998).

The complete catalog for the 1962-1998 period was the initial raw data for the probabilistic seismic hazard analysis. The final data set was obtained after tests for completeness and removal of dependent events (Lin et al., 1997). Tests indicated that a cut-off magnitude of 2.0 assured completeness of data throughout New Mexico with a substantial margin of safety. Dependent events were identified and removed using moving time and space windows of 7 days and 4 km for the SSA, and 7 days and 25 km for the events in the remainder of the state. For the hazard analysis, we considered only two source zones, the SSA and the remainder of New Mexico (RNM).

For modeling recurrence relations for the two source zones, a truncated exponential recurrence model was adopted. A Poisson distribution with upper and lower bound magnitudes of 6.5 and 2.0 was assumed. In estimating the slope b, the uncertainty in the measurement of magnitudes was taken into account (Bender, 1983) and produced a combined value of 0.692 for the two source zones.

The region was divided into 20 X 20 km2 blocks, the size of the blocks set to accommodate the maximum horizontal epicenter error for most of the earthquakes in the data set. Each block had its own recurrence relationship and during the hazard analysis interacted with neighboring blocks. The cumulative number of events in the recurrence model for each block was a combination of 75% of the events that occurred in the block plus 25% background seismicity. The latter was based on the average earthquake activity in 20 X 20 km2 blocks throughout the state. For each block, probabilities of occurrence were calculated for ground accelerations ranging from 0.01g to 0.36g at 0.05g intervals. The value of the maximum horizontal ground acceleration was interpolated directly from the curve. For Figure 4, 1480 probability-ground acceleration curves were evaluated.

 

Acknowledgments

We would like to acknowledge the contributions to our earthquake catalog by Los Alamos National Laboratory (Ken Olsen, Dan Cash, and Leigh House), the U.S. Geological Survey, and the University of Texas at El Paso (Diane Doser and G. Randy Keller).

References

Ake, J. P., and A. R. Sanford (1988). New evidence for existence and internal structure of a thin layer of magma at mid-crustal depths near Socorro, New Mexico, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 78, 1335-1359.

Ake, J. P., A. R. Sanford, and S. J. Jarpe (1983). A magnitude scale for central New Mexico based on signal duration, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology Geophysics Open-File Report 45, Socorro, New Mexico, 26 pp.

Aldrich, M. J., Jr., and A. W. Laughlin (1984). A model for the tectonic development of the southeastern Colorado Plateau boundary, J. Geophys. Res. 89, 10207-10218.

Antolik, M., R. M. Nadeau, R. C. Aster, and T. V. McEvilly (1996). Differential analysis of coda Q using similar microearthquakes in seismic gaps. Part 2: Application to seismograms recorded by the Parkfield High Resolution Seismic Network, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 86, 890-910.

Asada, T. (1957). Observations of near-by microearthquakes with ultra sensitive seismometers, J. Phys. Earth 5, 83-113.

Aster, R. and P. Shearer (1991). High-Frequency borehole seismograms recorded in the San Jacinto fault zone, Southern California. Part 1: Polarizations, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 81, 1057-1080.

Aster, R. and P. Shearer (1991). High-frequency borehole seismograms recorded in the San Jacinto fault zone, Southern California Part 2: Attenuation and Site Effects, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 81, 1081-1100.

Aster, R. and P. Shearer (1992). Initial shear-wave particle motions and stress constraints at the Anza seismic network, 1992. Geophys. J. Int. 108, 740-748.

Aster, R. and J. Scott (1993). Comprehensive identification of similar earthquakes in microearthquake data sets, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 83, 1307-1314.

Aster, R., P. Shearer, and J. Berger (1991). Reply to `Comment on "Quantitative measurements of shear wave polarizations at the Anza seismic network, Southern California: Implications for shear wave splitting and earthquake prediction'' by Richard C. Aster, Peter M. Shearer, and Jon Berger', J. Geophys. Res. 96, 6415-6419.

Aster, R., G. Slad, J. Henton, and M. Antolik (1996). Differential analysis of coda Q using similar microearthquakes in seismic gaps. Part 1: Techniques and application to seismograms recorded in the Anza seismic gap, southern California, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 86, 868-889.

Aster, R., R. Meyer, G. Natale, A. Zollo, M. Martini, E. Dell Pezzo, R. Scarpa, and G. Iannaccone (1992). Seismic investigation of the Campi Flegrei: A summary and synthesis of results, in Volcanic Seismology, Proc. Vol. 3\fR, Gasparini, P., Scarpa, R., Aki, K. (Editors), Springer Verlog, Heidelberg, 1992.

Balch, R. S., H. E. Hartse, A. R. Sanford, and K. W. Lin (1997). A new map of the geographic extent of the Socorro midcrustal magma body, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 87, 174-182.

Bender, B. (1983). Maximum likelihood estimation of b values for magnitude grouped data, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 73, 831-852.

Brocher, T. M. (1981). Geometry and physical properties of the Socorro, New Mexico, magma bodies, J. Geophys. Res. 86, 9420-9432.

Brown, L. D., C. E. Chapin, A. R. Sanford, S. Kaufman and J. Oliver (1980). Deep structure of the Rio Grande rift from seismic reflection profiling, J. Geophys. Res. 85, 4773-4800.

Brown, L. D., P. A. Krumhansl, C. E. Chapin, A. R. Sanford, F. A. Cook, S. Kaufman, J. E. Oliver, and F. S. Schilt (1979). COCORP seismic reflection studies of the Rio Grande rift, in Rio Grande rift: Tectonics and Magmatism, R. E. Riecker (Editor), American Geophysical Union, 169-184.

Carpenter, P. J. and A. R. Sanford (1985). Apparent Q for upper crustal rocks of the central Rio Grande rift, J. Geophys. Res. 90, 8661-8674.

Carpenter, P. J., A. R. Sanford and J. P. Ake (1987). A technique to obtain a Q(f) model from microearthquake swarms, Geophs. Res. Letters 14, 828-831.

Chapin, C. E. (1971). The Rio Grande rift: Part 1, Modifications and additions. New Mex. Geol. Soc., 22nd Annual Field Conference Guidebook, 191-201.

Chapin, C. E. (1979). Evolution of the Rio Grande rift: A summary, in Rio Grande Rift: Tectonics and Magmatism, R. E. Riecker (editor), American Geophysical Union, Washington, D.C., 1-5.

Chapin, C. E., R. M. Chamberlin, G. R. Osburn, D. W. White, and A. R. Sanford (1978). Exploration framework of the Socorro geothermal area, New Mexico, New Mexico Geological Society Special Publication 7, 115-129.

Haase, J., P. Shearer, and R. Aster (1995). Constraints on temporal variations in velocity near Anza, California, from analysis of similar event pairs, Bull Seism. Soc. Am. 85, 194-206.

Hammond, J. F. (1966). A Surgeon's Report on Socorro, New Mexico, 1852, Stagecoach Press, Santa Fe, New Mexico, 47 pp.

Hanks, T. C., and H. Kanamori (1979). A moment magnitude scale, J. Geophys. Res. 84, 2348-2350.

Hanson, M. E. and A. R. Sanford (1970). A two-dimensional source function for a dynamic brittle bilateral tensile crack, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 60, 1209-1219.

Hanson, M. E. and A. R. Sanford (1971). Some characteristics of a propagating brittle tensile crack, Geophys. Jour. Royal. Astro. Soc. 24, 231-244.

Hanson, M. E., A. R. Sanford and R. J. Shaffer (1971). A source function for a dynamic bilateral brittle shear fracture, J. Geophys. Res. 76, 3375-3385.

Hanson, M. E., A. R. Sanford and R. J. Shaffer (1974). A source function for a dynamic unilateral shear fracture, Geophys. Jour. Royal. Astro. Soc. 38, 365-376.

Hartse, H. E. (1991). Simultaneous hypocenter and velocity model estimation using direct and reflected phases from microearthquakes recorded within the central Rio Grande rift, Ph.D. Dissertation, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology, Socorro, New Mexico, 251 pp.

Hartse, H. E., A. R. Sanford, and J. S. Knapp (1992). Incorporating Socorro magma body reflections in to the earthquake location process, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 82, 2511-2532.

Hartse, H., M. Fehler, R. Aster, J. Scott, and F. Vernon (1994). Small-Scale stress heterogeneity in the Anza seismic gap, southern California, J. Geophys. Res. 99, 6801-6818.

Jaksha, L. H. and A. R. Sanford (1986). Earthquakes near Albuquerque, New Mexico, 1976 1981, J. Geophys. Res. 91, 6293-6303.

Klein, R. W. (1978). Hypocenter location program HYPOINVERSE Part I: Users guide to versions 1, 2, 3 and 4, U.S. Geol. Surv. Open-File Report 78-694.

Larsen, S., R. Reilinger, and L. Brown (1986). Evidence for ongoing crustal deformation related to magmatic activity near Socorro, New Mexico, J. Geophys. Res. 91, 6283-6292.

Lee, W. H. K. and J. C. Lahr (1975). HYPO71 (Revised): A computer program for determining hypocenter, magnitude, and first motion pattern of local earthquakes, U.S. Geol. Surv. Open-File Rept. 75-311.

Lin, K. W. (1994). Regional earthquake hypocenter location using a fuzzy logic algorithm enhanced SEISMOS program, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology Geophysics Open-File Report 74, Socorro, New Mexico, 82 pp.

Lin, K. W. (1999). Probabilistic seismic hazard in New Mexico and bordering areas, Ph.D. Dissertation, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology, Socorro, New Mexico, 194 pp.

Lin, K. W., and A. R. Sanford (1998). Effects of active faults on probabilistic seismic hazard estimates for the Socorro area using instrumental data from 1962 through 1995, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology Geophysics Open-File Report 88, Socorro, New Mexico, 15 pp.

Lin, K. W., and A. R. Sanford (1998). Improving locations of regional earthquakes using a modified G matrix, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology Geophysics Open-File Report 90, Socorro, New Mexico, 26 pp.

Lin, K. W., A. R. Sanford, and I. C. Tsai (1997). Probabilistic seismic hazard estimates for New Mexico using instrumental data from 1962 through 1995, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology Geophysics Open-File Report 84, Socorro, New Mexico, 12 pp.

Machette, M. N., S. F. Personius, K. I. Kelson, K. M. Haller, and R. L. Dart (1998). Map and data for Quaternary faults and folds in New Mexico, U.S. Geol. Surv., Open-File Report 98-521, 443 pp.

Newton, C. A., D. J. Cash, K. H. Olsen, and E.F. Homuth (1976). LASL seismic programs in the vicinity of Los Alamos, New Mexico, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory Informal Report LA 6406-MS, 42 pp.

Northrop, S. A. and A. R. Sanford (1972). Earthquakes of northeastern New Mexico and the Texas Panhandle, New Mex. Geol. Soc. 23rd Field Conf. Guidebook, 148-160.

Ouchi, S. (1983). Effects of uplift on the Rio Grande over the Socorro magma body, New Mexico, New Mexico Geological Society 34th Annual Field Conference Guidebook, 54-56.

Reilinger, R., J. Oliver, L. Brown, A. Sanford and E. Balazs (1980). New measurements of crustal doming over the Socorro magma body, New Mexico, Geology 8, 291-295.

Reiter, L. (1990). Earthquake Hazard Analysis: Issues and Insights, Columbia University Press, New York, 254 pp.

Richter, C. F. (1958). Elementary Seismology, W. H. Freeman, San Francisco, California, 768 pp.

Rinehart, E. J., and A. R. Sanford (1981). Upper crustal structure of the Rio Grande rift near Socorro, New Mexico, from inversion of microearthquake S-wave reflections, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 71, 437-450.

Rinehart, E. J., A. R. Sanford, and R. M. Ward (1979). Geographic extent and shape of an extensive magma body at mid-crustal depths in the Rio Grande rift near Socorro, New Mexico, in Rio Grande rift: Tectonics and Magmatism, R. E. Riecker (Editor), American Geophysical Union, 237-251.

Rowe, C., R. Aster, P. Kyle, J. Schlue, J., and R. Dibble (1998). Broadband recording of Strombolian explosions and associated very-long-period seismic signals on Mount Erebus volcano, Ross Island, Antarctica., Geophys. Res. Letters 25, 2297-2300.

Sanford, A. R. (1963). Seismic activity near Socorro, New Mex. Geol. Soc. 14th Field Conf. Guidebook, 146-151.

Sanford, A. R. (1965). An instrumental study of New Mexico earthquakes, New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources Circular 78, 12 pp.

Sanford, A. R. (1976). Seismicity of the Los Alamos region based on seismological data, Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory Informal Report LA-6416-MS, 9 pp.

Sanford, A. R. (1978). Characteristics of the Rio Grande rift in the vicinity of Socorro, New Mexico, from geophysical studies, New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources Circular 163, 12 pp.

Sanford, A. R. (1983). Magma bodies in the Rio Grande rift in central New Mexico, New Mex. Geol. Soc. 34th Field Conf. Guidebook, 127-131.

Sanford, A. R. (1998). An empirical relation between magnitude and maximum intensity for New Mexico earthquakes, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology Geophysics Open-File Report 86, Socorro, New Mexico, 4 pp.

Sanford, A. R. and P. Einarsson (1982). Magma chambers in rifts, in Continental and Oceanic Rifts, Geodynamics Series, 8, Palmason, G. (Editor), American Geophysical Union, 147-168.

Sanford, A. R. and C. R. Holmes (1961). Note on the July 1960 earthquakes in central New Mexico, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 51, 311-314.

Sanford, A. R. and C. R. Holmes (1962). Microearthquakes near Socorro, New Mexico, J. Geophys. Res. 67, 4449-4459.

Sanford, A. R. and K. W. Lin (1998). Evidence for a 1400 km long Socorro Fracture Zone, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology Geophysics Open-File Report 89, Socorro, New Mexico, 18 pp.

Sanford, A. R., and L. T. Long (1965). Microearthquake crustal reflections, Socorro, New Mexico, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 55, 579-586.

Sanford, A. R. and T. R. Toppozada (1974). Seismicity of proposed radioactive waste disposal site in New Mexico, New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources Circular 143, 15 pp.

Sanford, A. R., O. S. Alptekin, and T. R. Toppozada (1973). Use of reflection phases on microearthquake seismograms to map an unusual discontinuity beneath the Rio Grande rift, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 63, 2021-2034.

Sanford, A. R., R. S. Balch, and K. W. Lin (1995). A seismic anomaly in the Rio Grande rift near Socorro, New Mexico, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology Geophysics Open-File Report 78, Socorro, New Mexico, 18 pp.

Sanford, A. R., L. H. Jaksha, and D. J. Cash (1991). Seismicity of the Rio Grande rift in New Mexico, in Neotectonics of North America, D. B. Slemmons, E. R. Engdahl, M. D. Zoback, and D. D. Blackwell (Editors), Geological Society of America, 229-244.

Sanford, A. R., K. W. Lin, and I. C. Tsai (1997). Preliminary seismicity map for New Mexico and bordering areas, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology Geophysics Open-File Report 83, Socorro, New Mexico, 2 pp.

Sanford, A. R., K. H. Olsen, and L. H. Jaksha (1979). Seismicity of the Rio Grande rift, in Rio Grande rift: Tectonics and Magmatism, R. E. Riecker (Editor), American Geophysical Union, 145-168.

Sanford, A. R., K. H. Olsen, and L. H. Jaksha (1979). Earthquakes in New Mexico, 1849-1977, New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources Circular 171, 20 pp.

Sanford, A.R., K. W. Lin, I. C. Tsai, and L. H. Jaksha (1995). Preliminary listing and discussion of New Mexico earthquakes 1962-1994 with duration magnitudes of 3.0 or greater, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology Geophysics Open-File Report 79, Socorro, New Mexico, 13 pp.

Sanford, A. R., A. J. Budding, J. P. Hoffman, O. S. Alptekin, C. A. Rush, and T. R. Toppozada (1972). Seismicity of the Rio Grande rift zone in New Mexico, New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources Circular 120, 19 pp.

Sanford, A. R., R. P. Mott, Jr., P. J. Shuleski, E. J. Rinehart, F. J. Caravella, R. H. Ward, and T. C. Wallace (1977). Geophysical evidence for a magma body in the crust in the vicinity of Socorro, New Mexico, in The Earth’s Crust, Heacock, J. G. (Editor), American Geophysical Union, Geophysical Monograph 20, 385-403.

Savage, J. C., M. Lisowski, and W. H. Prescott (1985). Strain accumulation in the Rocky Mountain States, J. Geophys. Res. 90, 10310-10320.

Savage, J. C., M. Lisowski, W. H. Prescott, and A. R. Sanford (1980). Geodetic measurement of horizontal deformation across the Rio Grande rift near Socorro, New Mexico, J. Geophys. Res. 85, 7215-7220.

Schlue, J., R. Aster, and R. Meyer (1996). A lower-crustal extension to a mid-crustal magma body in the Rio Grande rift, New Mexico, J. Geophys. Res. 101, 25283-25291.

Sheetz, K. E. and J. W. Schlue (1992). Inferences for the Socorro magma body from teleseismic receiver functions, Geoph. Res. Letters 19, 1867-1870.

Singer, P. J. (1989). Crustal structure in the Socorro area of the Rio Grande rift from time-term analysis, Ph.D. Dissertation, New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology, Socorro, New Mexico, 206 pp.

Thelin, G. P., and R. J. Pike (1991). Landforms of the conterminous United States - a digital shaded-reflect portrayal, Misc. Investigation Series Map I-2206, U.S. Geol. Survey, U.S. Dept. of Interior.

Toppozada, T. R. and A. R. Sanford (1976). Crustal structure in central New Mexico interpreted from the GASBUGGY explosion, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 66, 877-886.

Ward, R. M., J. Wm. Schlue and A. R. Sanford (1981). Three-dimensional velocity anomalies in the upper crust near Socorro, New Mexico, Geophys. Res. Letters 8, 553-556.

Withers, M., R. Aster, C. Young, J. Beiringer, M. Harris, S. Moore, and J. Trujillo (1998). A comparison of select trigger algorithms for automated global seismic phase and event detection, Bull. Seism. Soc. Am. 88, 95-106.